• ALL
  • NEWS
    • GAY MOVIE/ENTERTAINMENT NEWS
    • GAY FILM TRAILERS
    • GENERAL MOVIE NEWS & TRAILERS
  • GAY SHORTS & SERIES
  • REVIEWS
    • GAY FILM REVIEWS
    • CINEMA REVIEWS
    • DVD & BLU-RAY REVIEWS
  • BGPS BLOG
  • COMPS
  • ABOUT
    • Contact Us
    • Join The Team
    • Terms & Conditions
    • Gays On Film – A Short History

Big Gay Picture Show

Taking a look at the world of film through gay eyes - news, reviews, trailers, gay film, queer cinema and more

Taking a look at the world of film through gay eyes - news, reviews, trailers, gay film, queer cinema & more

Frantz (DVD Review) – Is Francois Ozon’s film a gay post-war movie or not? Truth is complex

July 8, 2017 By Tim Isaac Leave a Comment

Starring: Pierre Niney, Paula Beer, Ernst Stötzner, Marie Gruber, Johann von Bülow
Director: Francois Ozon
Running Time: 113 mins
Certificate: 12
Release Date: July 10th 2017

I’ve generally shied away from covering movies on BGPS where the gay content is all down to interpretation, but it’s well worth reviewing Frantz here – a film that could either be very gay or barely at all depending on how you look at it. Just from reading the synopsis I suspected that it might be a film like that, due to the presence of director Francois Ozon (Swimming Pool, 8 Women), a filmmaker whose career has been marked by a strong interest in female characters, gay desire, and how different people interpret the same things.

It’s just after World War I, and in a small German town a young woman called Anna (Paula Beer) is still in mourning for her fiancé – Frantz – who she lost in the trenches of France. She lives with her fallen boyfriend’s parents – Hans (Ernst Stötzner) and Magda (Marie Gruber) – who are also still reeling from the loss.

When she visits Frantz’s (empty) grave, she is surprised to find fresh flowers there that neither she nor Frantz’s parents left. She is told they were put there by a mysterious Frenchman who has arrived in town. The visitor is Adrien (Pierre Niney), who has travelled to Germany in memory of Frantz. He tells Anna, Hans and Magda about how he and Frantz were friends in Paris before the war, but that world events caused them to end up as soldiers on different sides of an almighty conflict – one of them surviving while the other didn’t.

However, there is far more to this tale than Adrien first reveals, which eventually leads Anna to Paris, revisiting the place Frantz would have known as a student, as she attempts to track Adrien down.

Inspired by Ernst Lubitsch’s 1932 movie, Broken Lullaby, which in turn was based on a play by Maurice Rostand, Frantz is a rather fascinating movie, playing with time, memory, forgiveness, romance, the traumas of war and the possibility for redemption, many of which are deliberately shown in ways that make them as relevant today as they were back in 1919. However, it doesn’t do it in a straightforward way, instead laying out a series of possibilities for the viewer to look at and decide what they mean, what is true and how that changes what is important to the story.

For example, you have characters finding strength and solace from reliving events that may never have happened. It plays with the idea that sometimes there is a better ‘truth’ than what actually occurred, especially if that factual truth is slowly destroying people, while a fictionalised reinterpretation may help them. Indeed, there’s a suggestion that the truth of what something represents is more important than the objective reality.

It’s a theme that runs right through the movie, such as how both the Germans and the French prefer to hate and blame each other for the war and for killing each other’s young men, so they don’t have to consider their own culpability (especially that it was the parents who encouraged their children to go off to war).

All the way through, what characters know and believe alters, often due to lack of information, but other times due to a wilful decision to either lie or to find solace in what they know isn’t strictly true. It allows it to be a powerful look at both war and people picking up the pieces afterwards, while also speaking to how we all live our lives – ignoring truths that don’t fit with what we’d like to believe, and turning things into narratives that are far less messy, complex and morally grubby than reality. It’s not just the characters either, as the viewer is also asked to question what they believe and what is true in the movie, and how the dissonance between the possibilities changes what they’re viewing.

That brings us to Adrien. It’s slightly difficult to talk about him without it being too much of a spoiler. However, right the way through the movie it’s possible to see him as a gay man or as a straight one. Normally that would be annoying – either a film unwilling to tell the truth or a too-pleased-with-itself filmmakers’ affectation. Here though it fits perfectly with a film where people are creating realities for both themselves and for the sake of others.

Adrien’s remembrances of Frantz are undoubtedly given a homoerotic edge and intimacy that he lacks in his other interactions – to the point that the flashbacks are so vibrant and intense that they’re one of the few colour sequences in an otherwise black and white movie. There is also a lover’s embrace between two men in a trench, but one where the embrace is forced rather than optional.

However, as we learn more, all this is brought into question – both in terms of the actual truth and what a remembrance of intimacy might actually mean. At no point is Adrien’s sexuality directly addressed, resulting in a scene towards the end that could be about a gay man and a straight woman, or two straight people in an impossible situation. What they could be getting from that moment may be completely different depending on how both the viewer and the characters interpret it, and it may be that in reality they are both the surrogate for the same person who isn’t there. It presents something where there are possible layers of truth, the least important of which is the objective reality.

Is he gay? Is he straight? And if he is gay, what does that mean about the ending, comparing what Anna believes has just happened with what may be going on in Adrien’s head? It’s certainly not a coincidence that Ozon is gay, and the original playwright, Maurice Rostand, was a closeted man too – so the movie is undoubtedly iffused with a gay sensibility, but the ‘truth’ about Adrien is left up to the viewer.

In most films, the objective truth is held up as the ultimate prize irrespective of the pain it may cause – but Frantz shows the world is more complex than that, and that even those who may say they only want truth, might really want something a little more comforting.

Overall Verdict: A gay-themed film, or not, depending on how both you and the characters want to interpret things. This exploration of the aftermath of war becomes a fascinating look at the nature of truth, how malleable it can become, and that we all create our own reality depending on what we think will help the most. Sometimes it may help, and other times it just helps us hide.

Reviewer: Tim Isaac

Special Features: Lights & Costume Testing,   ‘Frantz in Venice’ Featurette,   ‘Posters’ Featurette,   Deleted Scenes

OVERALL RATING:

Wanna share?:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Tumblr
  • Flipboard
  • More
  • Reddit
  • LinkedIn
  • Email
  • Print
  • Pocket
  • WhatsApp

Related

Filed Under: GAY FILM REVIEWS, Top Posts

Leave a Reply (if comment does not appear immediately, it may have been held for moderation) Cancel reply

Search this site:

We're Needy, Be Our Friend

RSSTwitterFacebookStumbleUponMySpace

E-maily Stuff

Get the latest in our daily e-mail

Most Recent Posts

Young Hunter Trailer – First teen gay love takes a dark turn into blackmail

Everybody’s Talking About Jamie Trailer – The hit gay, drag West End musical is coming to the screen

Iris Prize Festival LGBT+ International Short Films 2020 – Part 3 (Short Film Reviews)

Iris Prize Festival LGBT+ International Short Films 2020 – Part 2 (Short Film Reviews)

Iris Prize Festival LGBT+ International Short Films 2020 – Part 1 (Short Film Reviews)

The Scottish Queer International Film Festival 2020 Has Opened, & It’s Online Across The UK

The Iris Prize LGBT Short Film Festival Returns Next Week, & It’s Online & Free!

An Apology From Big Gay Picture Show

Win The Miseducation of Cameron Post DVD & Book!

Seventeen Trailer – The vagaries of teen romance erupt in the lesbian-themed film

My Best Friend Trailer – Gay romance flickers between two teen boys

New Sauvage Trailer – The gay prostitute movie that divided Cannes is coming soon

Copyright © 2023 Muser Media · Powered by WordPress & Genesis Framework · Log in

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're OK with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Read More Accept Reject
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT